Essay Analysis
September 30, 2024
There is one required essay (maximum 500 words) for all Tepper MBA applicants (except college seniors):
The Tepper School community is committed to helping students reach their full potential. Explain your philosophy on helping others achieve their full potential. How have you implemented this philosophy in your professional life, and what impact has it had on those around you? How will this philosophy influence your approach to leadership at the Tepper School and beyond?
We like this question. Mostly because we resonate with the ‘helping people reach their full potential’ M.O. This question is a bit sneaky, and may trick some folks. But not others. In that sense, it’s a neat way to let the competition sort itself out.
If you’re not careful, you’ll steer this essay too heavily in the direction of ‘helping others’ and throw so much focus on how thoughtful you are about empowering others, and how great a person you are to not just be all about self-betterment but really want to help the other guy, man how great and selfless and wonderful a person you are, and you can’t help yourself when it comes to anything, you’re just so damn mindful about making sure others are fed first because—
Business school, folks.
Let’s come at this a different way. How big is your business appetite? How huge can you dream? Not necessarily in terms of $$$ but bigness of the idea, impact, game-changing, real, powerful advancement of… the world, society, the whole enchilada? Guess what. True disruption, true success stories of ‘business that are built to last,’ true agents of change even on an individual level, are almost always achieved - not solo - but through the clever empowerment of others around you, to help achieve efficiency, and… scale. This is what CMU is after. Do you get the concept of ‘big’? And do you get that in order to think ‘big’ you have already recognized that the ‘biggest’ version requires the leadership of others? This is the ballgame, folks. You need to demonstrate that you get that, and that the way you’ve understood that is from personal experience, that has fueled your appetite to really blow things up: hence, business school.
So, here’s how we’re gonna about it:
- First, give us your understanding of what business success looks like. Don’t skimp here, and don’t rush. Really paint a picture, possibly in the abstract but more likely through a personal anecdote that demonstrates what success could have looked like, but what it ended up looking like, and how that cooler version was the result of a number of individuals who were operating at max potential, rowing in the same direction. (100-125 words)
- Now explain your hand in all of it. Don’t be afraid to wade into a prior version of yourself that didn’t quite have this realization yet, in case you choose an example of how you came to learn it firsthand. Either way, take us through the way in which you understood the value of (as well the challenges of) empowering others to succeed. Now, it doesn’t necessarily need to be an example of how you helped others ultimately help you––it can, truly, be about how you’ve helped others for its own sake. But it should be evident that you understand the ‘business’ implications of that. (125-150 words)
- Let’s go more general now, and talk about how, in general, you have applied this idea in other areas. One instance may be convenient, or a fluke. Several… becomes a pattern. We like patterns. We want to get the sense that this is now etched into your DNA as a leader. Show us a few examples here of where you’ve understood perhaps ‘an inconvenient’ truth about the effort required to helping others, perhaps even to some short-term cost to yourself. Show us why these were important moves, again, in a way that demonstrates your business sense, at the same time as it burnishes your ‘humanity’ credentials. (125-150 words)
- Now, let’s get into how ‘helping others’ is not overly intellectual, just a part of how you go about doing your thing. Think about what you’re hoping to learn from others at Tepper in kind, and then flip it and talk about what value you might add in the direction of helping others. Remember to frame it in a way that almost makes it seem like it’s not so much a ‘moral’ or ‘humane’ choice, but rather, ‘what you do cuz why wouldn’t you’? Like, it’s so stupidly obvious because it’s in everyone’s best interests that it’s just the most flatly obvious way to be. The best version of a response here comes from someone who ‘gets’ it so readily that it doesn’t seem that conscious. (100-125 words)
September 28, 2024
We know this is an important component of your decision to attend business school. We take it seriously as well.
Please describe your post-MBA career goals.
It would be helpful to consider the following information in your response:
- You have up to 2 minutes to respond to this question.
- Please be as specific as possible. If you have not yet identified specific companies, that is okay. Just tell us what interests you for your next role or company. What about the industry, company, or functional role is appealing to you?
- If you have any criteria you are using to evaluate career opportunities, please share those as well. We may have great opportunities to add to your list.
- How does this post-MBA career goal relate to your long-term career plan?
First we’ll unpack the themes and ideas of the content, then we’ll talk a little about the nuances of presenting this via video rather than written essay. Let’s dig.
Themes & Content
The key to this whole thing is ‘wow that makes so much sense.’ Lots to unpack here, so here goes:
- To have clarity around your goals, increases (by orders of magnitude) the likelihood that you will succeed at those goals… or any OTHER goals you set your mind to (the ‘any’ is key)
- To be able to express these articulately validates it, it is not easy. Those who can speak with clarity are more likely to be focused.
- To understand the precise ways in which each component of your past and future and every stage in between connect, and build on each other, further validates the question of whether you understand what’s necessary to succeed, and almost serves as a ‘guarantee’ that you are likely TO succeed. It’s a signal that you ‘get it’ and the folks who ‘get it’ eventually… get it. Business schools are trying to gamble on the sure things.
That’s the ballgame. It isn’t the case that your ideas themselves are going to impress. Adcoms are too smart for that. They recognize that ideas are not in short supply. Executors OF … any ideas… are. Doers. Follow-through-ers. Folks with the clarity and discipline to persevere when you’re past the honeymoon idea phase and shit gets real. The people who understand what the road ahead entails, and demonstrate a sobriety and tactical mindset are the ones who will impress adcoms. That’s what they’re looking for when they ask about your goals. They don’t care about the actual goals. They want to see the signals of someone who has the traits of an executor.
A 2-minute video roughly translates to maybe 250 words or so in writing, so let’s use that as a frame. Here’s how an ‘essay’ version might have read (with an eventual video presentation in mind):
- What’s your overall goal, the super end-end game? Think about it this way, don’t just give us the Title or Role, which tells us nothing. Think about the impact it will have once you achieve that position/goal. What has happened as a result of it, whose lives have been changed, what thing has been disrupted, what situation has improved, what is… the practical impact of it all. Do this very quickly to paint a picture of what motivates you … and every step you’re going to now take in order to move toward it. (50 words)
- What are the skills required to pull that off? By framing it this way, you can now take us through the chronological road map of how you’ll navigate each step and extract something very specific which launches you to the next step that builds on it, and then the next step, and so on. So begin with where you are now and why you need an MBA before you attack the step immediately following your MBA. (50-75 words)
- Next, take us through your vision for the very next move following CMU, ‘now’ loaded with this newfound MBA experience and improved skill set and network. (75 words)
- Finally, talk broadly about how you arrived at your plan, and address the criteria you used to evaluate career opportunities. On what basis did you choose LT Vision X, given your passions and skills? Can you frame this in a way that your motivating force is a root-level concept, and therefore not just limited to your idea for how to achieve that? CMU wants to know that they may be able to add value to your current sense of your future––after all, this is the whole point of business school to open up possibilities. This is a key part to nail. (50-75 words)
Just a few more words on this last part. You need to find the right balance of being not too broad and also not too narrow. For example: “I’m looking at career opportunities that will afford me a leadership position, such that I can lead people to achieve!” Cool. You’ve just said absolutely nothing of any substance, it includes, all the things. On the other end, you might say “I would like to become CEO of a tech company in Cupertino, California, whose name is that of a common fruit.” Implying that anything other than the CEO of Apple is of no interest. Too specific.
These are exaggerated almost to the point of being unhelpful, but it’s important to see the posts at both ends to understand why it’s important to find the perfect balance. Rather than say “I must be a CEO of a company in the tech space…” for example, you’re better off grappling with the end-result/impact OF that particular path. What’s the thing that results? “I want to find an opportunity that leads to the betterment of… X.” “I want to be in a position where I’m able to inspire teams to… Y.” This can lead you down a great path, that can be specific with respect to ‘impact’ and ‘outcome’ but open with respect to the ‘path’ which could be any number of things. You have a sense for what ‘the’ path is today, but what if CMU blows your mind and opens the door to newer opportunities you hadn’t even realized existed? Again, this is the point of business school. So, learn to traffic in ‘outcome’-speak, less ‘path’-speak.
You can still have a clear sense of the precise steps you’re going to take, don’t confuse that with our earlier point. The point we want to emphasize is that it should all be couched in a frame that’s focused on the outcome, not the path itself.
Video Presentation
Ever seen a *great* speech at a wedding, or the like? 9 out of 10 times, the speaker was ‘off book’ and not reading from a script. A perfectly-scripted response can be great. But what you lose is the connection with the audience, which is best achieved by speaking TO them, and not studying your notes. For a 2-minute video, this is an absolute must NOT to read from a script, but to be well acquainted with the contours of your ideas, that you can mentally jump from one bullet to the next, and say what you need to say succinctly, but differently each time you do it so that it feels fresh and unrehearsed, but still taut and efficient.
In order to achieve that level, you will likely need to practice like crazy. Here’s one way to do it when you have the benefit of ‘knowing what the question is ahead of time’ as you do here:
- Before you write anything, pull out your phone or laptop, get yourself on screen through whatever app you like that has a record function, and hit Record, and answer the prompt: ”Please describe your post-MBA career goals.” Do this raw, without having written anything down. Don’t fuss about time, take as much time as you need to get your points across. You may get through it all in one minute. Or you might hit ‘stop’ and see that 10 minutes have elapsed. Doesn’t matter. Record this first draft and then rewatch it in abject horror, haha. It’s going to suck, and that’s not only okay, it’s going to be liquid gold for what comes next.
- Now that you’ve gotten a garbage attempt out, and watched the horror show, you will have divined insights about where you were clunky, where the transitions were choppy, where your ideas don’t even sound that clear or coherent, but also, where you seemed to hit a solid note or two, and so on. Now, take your time and write out in essay form a more considered response. Make this sucker flow. Make it tight. Edit it, get it to a great place, but try not to get too stuck on precise wording. Instead you want to focus on thematic punches. What’s the meat of what you’re trying to get across, for the tightest and highest impact 250 word essay?
- Now, without keeping this written version in front of you (this is key, put that thing away, out of sight), record yourself again. You’ll notice two things have happened. You’ll be a LOT closer to the 2-min mark (having aimed at a 250-word piece), and your flow (especially if you’ve followed our guidance) will be a thousand times more coherent and compelling.
- Refine again, having reacted to where it’s strong, where it isn’t, etc. And write it out, get it to a great place. But this time, before you record again, condense your 250-word essay to … five (or so) bullets that are simply headlines that capture themes, to remind you of the key transitions. This would be the equivalent of using index cards (and btw, that’s a great way to do it, get some index cards, and write out one concept on each card, of all of em on one card, either way). Try recording again using only these BULLETS and see how well you can do to tell your entire story as coherently as possible. Review, and try it again, perhaps making a few adjustments to your index cards wording (maybe adding a key transition, changing the wording somewhat), and have another go. See how you do. Do it again. And again. And each time you do it, try to tell it a little differently each time so that the muscle memory builds around the concepts, not the words.
- This may feel silly at some point. But important stuff is happening on a level you’re not even aware of. At some point, possibly five recordings (or twenty) later, you’ll feel a click. Something will have shifted and you’ll … know your story inside-out. To the point where you might not even need the cards, you can hear the transitions because they’re so intuitive. If you’ve framed it correctly, the logical underpinnings should be so sound that written transition cues aren’t necessary because they’re baked into the ‘story’ itself. When this happens, you’re in a great place and you should take a break. Give it a day or two and then come back to it, stay somewhat fresh, but do not over-rehearse. If you do, you’ll start to get married to phrases and it’ll sound canned. This is the part that will sound controversial but a story that’s 90% perfect in wording but 100% sound in logic and FEELS UNREHEARSED will outperform a story that’s 100% ‘perfect’ and 100% sound in logic but DOES FEEL REHEARSED. A little bit raw (with a sound logical foundation) beats an overly rehearsed performance any day of the week. This is a skill you’re going to develop in business school no matter what so, start training now!
September 27, 2024
Short answer question (150 words): What are your post-undergraduate career plans? What company are you joining? What will be your role?
150 words isn’t a lot, which is nice. A good excuse to be straightforward and to the point. But with your future-business-school cap on, you want to frame this as ‘things you’re planning to do… with business school in mind as an inevitable and important component of your overall plan.’ So let’s start there. What is your long-term goal (such as you’re aware of it today), such that an MBA is a necessary stepping stone? What is it you’re hoping to do eventually? What’s the role, function? If you achieve all of it, what will the impact of your efforts be? Okay, now that you have a sense of that, work backwards.
Why is it that in order to achieve that, you’ll need an MBA specifically? What would it have looked like without an MBA? And now, replay it, and how does an MBA turbocharge that effort? Be specific. Great. Keep working backwards. In order to get into an MBA program, what kind of experience must you first get? Why? What are your skills today, and what skills will you need to develop in order to be productive at an MBA program? In other words, you might try your hand at an MBA program ‘today.’ But an interesting alternative would be to gain from real-life experience doing … something… such that an MBA experience after that would make it 100x more productive. How does that argument go? Now you’re ready to tackle this question.
- Give us the big picture very quickly. What’s the long-term vision? One sentence, maybe two.
- Now explain what skills will be crucial to succeeding at that effort, and complete this thought by explaining what portion of that you have, and more important don’t have, and are hoping to develop. This should break down into two pieces: (1) The MBA, but before that (2) Your very next steps, this next job, the company you’re going to join, the role, and what you’re hoping to accomplish there, and why.
- Tie it all together and show us step-by-step how each phase leads elegantly to the next.
Essay question (350-500 words): Why is our Tepper Future Business Leaders format a good fit for your MBA program?
What research have you done on possible business school options for you, given your current phase (still in college)? What are the features of an ideal business school, given your goals, and your particular profile/background/skill set? At this point, you will have established what *an* ideal program looks like, and how it would bring out the best in you given your specific profile and circumstances. Now take us through the specific ways in which several features of the Tepper Future Business Leaders format suits you in a way that is noteworthy, and makes for a particularly good fit. You can do this by drawing contrasts with other programs, indicating specific aspects of CMU that ‘meet the brief’ best/better.
- Describe the conditions in which you thrive - academically, socially, all of it. Show us examples from your recent past.
- Now take us through your business goals, and what a business school experience might look like that would deliver the greatest ‘enhancing’ effect on you and your goals, given that stuff from Bullet Point #1 above.
- Now go through your specific examples of how, after your meticulous research efforts (and you’ll tell us what these have been), the CMU offering is the best of the bunch. How, why, where’s the evidence for this? Connect the CMU opportunities specifically to your goals, your optimal learning environment, all of it. Make the case that given who you are, the combo of you + CMU is the best combo of all possible combos. Easier said than done. The only way to succeed here is to make a compelling case of how if you were to land at another program, sure you would succeed, but it wouldn’t be *the best* version, given specific opportunities available at CMU.
September 26, 2024
The Tepper School of Business is proud to be a long-standing member of The Consortium. Applicants should submit their application via The Consortium application.
The mission of the Consortium for Graduate Study in Management, an alliance of more than 20 graduate business schools and some of our country’s top corporations, is to enhance diversity in business education and leadership by helping to reduce the under-representation of African Americans, Hispanic Americans, and Native Americans in both its member schools’ enrollment and the ranks of management.
The Consortium fulfills its mission by attracting and recruiting qualified candidates from underrepresented groups, as well as other U.S. citizens or U.S. permanent residents who have demonstrated significant contributions to promoting diversity in the workplace.
Tepper supplemental application includes the following essay topic:
The Tepper School community is committed to helping students reach their full potential. Explain your philosophy on helping others achieve their full potential. How have you implemented this philosophy in your professional life, and what impact has it had on those around you? How will this philosophy influence your approach to leadership at the Tepper School and beyond? (maximum 500 words)
This is the same question posed to first time MBA applicants, check out “Carnegie Mellon (CMU) Tepper Business School MBA Essay” above!
September 25, 2024
Check out analysis of the Optional Essay and Re-Applicant essay here:
View more essay analyses.
Need help with your
essay writing?
We got you.
Our Success Continues
#Humble Brag
Take a look at our case studies, and see if you can start discovering the winning patterns connecting all successful candidates!
Learn MoreAdmissionado Tool
The IMPACT Tool
Check out the theory behind our unique approach to distilling MBA admissions to these six profile features.
Learn More