Essay Analysis
September 10, 2024
*Updated August 2024*
Brown's Open Curriculum allows students to explore broadly while also diving deeply into their academic pursuits. Tell us about any academic interests that excite you, and how you might pursue them at Brown. (200-250 words)
Understanding the ‘Open Curriculum’
What IS the Open Curriculum at Brown? Well, in a nutshell, it’s the opposite of the CORE CURRICULUM that you’ll find at other schools. Is it better or worse… that’s for others to debate. Brown is giving you a blank canvas. Sorta. There’s a common misconception that the Open Curriculum is literally open season on taking whatever you want, whenever you want, throughout your four years at Brown. Not so much. You will still have to declare a Major (they call it something else at Brown, usually “Concentration”), like anywhere else. And that Major (and Minor, if you do more than one thing) will require a long set of classes in order for you to graduate successfully.
So not really “open” in the literal sense. The true spirit of the Open Curriculum lies in the freedom afforded to every student to find their own way TOWARD their “area of focus.” Brown requires that you get focused by the end of your sophomore year. They just don’t give you many rules about what you have to do in those first two years. With the exception of Engineering majors, you are free to take courses in any area, whenever, however, etc. There’s also the ability to potentially create a curriculum of your own, but there’s a process for that, and not everyone’s idea gets approved.
There’s more to be said about the Open Curriculum, and you should do some reading on it, as well as chat with Brown alums (no better way than that) and get THEIR take on the reality. The key for our purposes though is that it’s kind of Brown’s “thing.” Something they’re famous for, even if other schools have similarly lax restrictions on what courses you can take.
And here’s the important part: it’s all about self-authorship. Brown doesn’t just embrace the notion that you should be in full control over channeling your skills and talents toward something meaningful, but that the folks who naturally tune into the frequency of their own compass, rather than adapting themselves to someone else’s prescription of what you should pursue… are the kinds of folks Brown University wants to ‘gamble on’ as they compete with other schools hoping to produce successful, productive contributors to society. Seems a subtle distinction, but there’s an important insight here: that trait (self-authoring, making one’s own way, blazing trails, disrupting, challenging, forging, etc.) is *the* trait Brown University is interested not just in cultivating, but sourcing from the get go.
Tying this all up in a bow: if you can demonstrate in your essays that you have an established pattern of being proactive, challenging the status quo, making the most of opportunities available to you, creating opportunities where they may not be readily available… you will instantly become appealing in Brown’s eyes as someone who will not just ‘be a good fit for Brown’s ethos’ but, indirectly, signal to Brown that you have the stuff they *they* believe will be a harbinger of future success. (That’s the ‘what’s in it for them’ angle, which is crucial to understand.)
Now, to dissect the prompt itself.
Let’s take for rote *that* you have academic interests. It’s okay to be ‘interested’ in a subject, if even for purely practical reasons: “I am interested in Chemistry, even if there’s no obvious way in which anything I learn here will intersect in any way shape or form with what I eventually spend the rest of my days doing.” “I am interested in taking Mathematics even though I am not mathematically inclined, but I want to stretch, develop some well-roundedness, but I’m finding that despite my learning about sine and cosine, my opinion of triangles has not changed significantly.”
And thus, Brown wants to focus you on ‘interests’ … that ‘excite you.’ Out of all the subjects available to you, which ones stir something in you? Which ones turned you from a non-believer to a believer? Or from a casually interested person to an ‘omg, must learn everything about this subject tonight.’ Hold that thought for a second––let’s look at the second piece of the puzzle.
The ‘how might you pursue them at Brown’ is interesting. It is assumed that you’ll be able to pursue these interests at any college on planet Earth. In fact, let’s take it a step further. Imagine you get accepted to Brown, but also Stanford, and Harvard, and Princeton. While it is true that you would be able to pursue your academic interests at ANY of those fine institutions, and end up perfectly successful and fulfilled if you play your cards right… there may still be a chance that the version of you that passes through Brown––given the quirks of its curriculum, and Brown’s general culture, its specific offerings––confers a marginal benefit that is of particular interest to you. Try to locate what that might be. So, you imagine four scenarios:
- Version 1 - Pursue your interests at Harvard.
- Version 2 - Pursue your interests at Stanford.
- Version 3 - Pursue your interests at Princeton.
- Version 4 - Pursue your interests at *Brown*.
Why is Version 4 cooler? What is it about Brown that excites you even more? Why is the version of you that travels through Brown somehow better off, happier, more stimulated, better able to advance your interests and extract from your collegiate experience?
Okay, so now that you’ve gone through that thought exercise, let’s synthesize.
- Start by explaining which academic interests either turned you from not being interested to being super interested, or took a middling interest and amplified it into something all-consuming! Why? Can you show us evidence of this interest playing out in real life? Make it so that we can picture it. Show us how your interest here goes to a different level from another person who is ‘very interested’ but not ‘ridiculously interested.’
- Next, explain what you hope to do with this on ‘a’ college campus, and what types of opportunities you’re hoping to have that would enable you to really dig in, broaden your horizons, double-down, level up, etc.
- Now explain that while most colleges will enable this desire well enough, there’s something particular to Brown that gives it an edge in enabling you even more/better. Be as specific as possible. Are there specific professors, or clubs, or opportunities that you’ve come to learn about that are unique to Brown that support your claim?
It always falls flat when students make it seem like Brown is ‘the only’ place that could possibly support their interest in XYZ. We know for a fact that it isn’t true. The stronger argument acknowledges that you can pursue this anywhere and everywhere (in fact, Brown wants you to make it clear that you don’t need Brown to help you with these interests, because you are determined, and as someone who is self-authoring their way, you’ll simply … find a way no matter what). But, that the opportunities that ARE readily available at Brown (including the freedom to carve up stuff with more flexibility than you might find elsewhere), that of all the options, this one has unusual appeal, and has a slight edge. Two crisp paragraphs for those three bullets, and you’ll end up with a killer first draft.
October 10, 2019
Tell us about a place or community you call home. How has it shaped your perspective? (250 word limit)
Once again, this comes down to “did this kid write this expecting/hoping me to be impressed?” Or… did this kid actually just write an authentic, thoughtful answer to this question? That second one is GOLD. The first one, garbage. Out of 10 attempts at answering this question, how many do you think answer it “the garbage way”? Seriously, take a guess.
Answer: 9.7 (at least)
That’s right, it is the absolute EXCEPTIONAL APPLICANT who doesn’t write this FOR an admissions committee reader. Most do, and it’s always trash. Very, very, very few applicants have the courage to write truly authentically. Maybe that’s why admissions rates are so low (stands to reason).
Don’t try to sound poetic here, folks. Don’t try to be Johnny Deep. That isn’t to say “be straightforward.” That’s not what we’re saying at all… It’s possible to be earnest AND thoughtful. Let’s dig in a bit.
First things first. Let’s get our heads around that word “home.” What does that mean? It’s not purely a physical dwelling, cuz, enough people will have that same essential answer, which therefore tells us nothing about any single individual, right? And that’s not what Brown is going for here.
Each individual’s interpretation of the word “home” will vary (we hope it does!). For some it might mean “where do I feel safest.” For others it might mean “where I feel most myself.” For others it might be “where I feel most emotionally secure.” Could be “most relaxed.” Can be lots of things. While it would be inefficient to go through each possible interpretation, one thing we CAN do is talk about the TYPE of answers that are most effective here. Answer? The ones that are REVEALING…
One of our favorite “tips” at Admissionado is to find an answer here that might SURPRISE a reader who is very close to you. Who knows you the BEST? Mom? Best friend? Sibling? Imagine someone asked them this question on your behalf. In other words, someone asked them to guess what YOU would define as “home.” They take their best guess based on how ridiculously well they know you. If you were to show them your answer, here’s what SHOULD happen… they should finish reading and say “Holy crap, I thought I knew you!” That would be amazing. Not necessary, but that’s one way to test whether you’re on the right track.
Here’s another cool test. If you think you have a good answer for this question, but you worry that “someone else reading this might have a hard time understanding what you mean” … that’s a FANTASTIC sign. Those often make for the BEST essays. Don’t worry, you’ll make it understandable through the re-writing process, but as a “soul” of an essay, one that “someone else” will have trouble accessing immediately… is gold.
The flip side to all this is true also. If others reading this would correctly predict your topic, and others reading it would easily understand where you’re coming from, chances are… you haven’t dug deep enough. Or, you’ve dug plenty, and your response simply isn’t coooool enough (not your fault, but you may have to get creative here).
[It’s possible to have a lot of FUN with this one, too. Of all the prompts that are ripe for cheekiness, this one’s ripest of them all. At the core, however, there must be evidence of some serious, “intellectual” thought. It doesn’t matter how creative the style is—there has to substance too.]
Now, let’s just dig into organization briefly, because there are two pieces you need to hit (and not necessarily in this order):
- What “your” perspective is, such that it might have been shaped by something. We need to understand how your perspective differs from someone else’s. So imagine a thing that most people have a standard way of perceiving, or describing, or experiencing. And now imagine how YOUR version is somehow a little different. Our first challenge is to identify WHAT is different about, and be able to describe it.
- The second task is to figure out what the “winds” were that shaped that perspective quirk to begin with. Once you start to get a handle on this, it should give you clues about the overlap areas between the perspectives that define you AND the “place/community” you call home.
Keep in mind that not all things that shape you are welcome/pleasant. And some things that have shaped you may very well belong to a category you decidedly feel is the OPPOSITE of home. That’s useful to keep in mind as you wrap your mind around the stuff that shaped you AND is also is very much linked to the place/community you consider home.
October 10, 2019
At Brown, you will learn as much from your peers outside the classroom as in academic spaces. How will you contribute to the Brown community? (250 words)
Well, actually, we would argue that you stand to learn MORE from your peers outside the classroom than inside, but that’s a discussion for a different day!
Rather than use this space to demonstrate your interest in Brown, and to reveal things you know about Brown, our perspective here is to TURN THE TABLES. Some folks may have a different take here. (But ours is better, haha.)
Let’s think about this critically. Presumably, you have tons to give, right? Presumably, you have cool perspectives on things shaped by the circumstances of your upbringing (where your family is from, specific family dynamics, geography, socioeconomic status, whatever other influences exist that can shape a human). You have your talents, your interests, your passions, your personality quirks. You’re like a tightly wound coil, brimming with potential energy. Will that change if you end up at . . . Harvard? Or Yale? Or Stanford? Or Columbia? Or Cornell? Why would it? I mean, it’s possible that you’ll adapt to an environment that’s different, as anyone would, but would your contributions TO that environment fundamentally shift? If so, doesn’t that make … what you have to give… kinda flimsy? Shouldn’t your offerings be… your offerings… REGARDLESS of where you end up?
The badass answer here is yah, you’re going to contribute a ton of amazing stuff to WHICHEVER SCHOOL *YOU* END UP CHOOSING. This is the part where you (a) reveal what that is, (b) make Brown want you to contribute that stuff to Brown and NOT another program, so they can have you all for themselves.
Rather than go too hard on why you want to make that contribution to BROWN and not another school, go hard on what it is you have to contribute, and what it is you’re hoping OTHERS have to contribute that’ll enrich YOUR experience. It’s almost like you’re laying down YOUR demands to Brown here and challenging them to make you want THEM over another option.
Now, how do you do all that? Well first you have to establish what it is you’re hoping to get out of the “learning from peers” aspect. Can you point to a time when you’ve been better off for having been in the presence of others, in an outside-the-classroom situation? Something where, had you experienced it alone, you might have still succeeded or had a positive outcome, but it wouldn’t have been as rich? You’ll want to establish (from experience) your humility, and awareness of how much others can contribute to your own growth, and to explain what qualities made that possible. Once you’ve established that, now it’s time to offer a kind of quid pro quo, as if to say, “and now for MY part in this bi-directional peer-to-peer learning exchange!” This is what *I* bring to the party: A, B, C, etc.
What’s “A B C, etc.”? Well, it’s different for every individual. That’s the whole point. There has to be a way for you imagine how others experiencing college without you ends up being an A-, say. But that an alternate version that includes you along the way, elevates that “same” experience to an A+. What was in that you were able to provide, by way of fresh perspective, or talent, or energy, or an unusual passion, or your way of thinking, that could possibly have a rub-off effect like that? This is your opportunity to showcase how you’ve influenced others thus far, and what specific qualities you have to continue to contribute to the Brown campus. (Or any campus, for that matter.)
View more essay analyses.
Need help with your
essay writing?
We got you.
Our Success Continues
#Humble Brag
Take a look at our case studies, and see if you can start discovering the winning patterns connecting all successful candidates!
Learn MoreAdmissionado Tool
The IMPACT Tool
Check out the theory behind our unique approach to distilling MBA admissions to these six profile features.
Learn More